Harry Potter and

Chatterbox: Pudding's Place

Harry Potter and

Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince came out today. I've just got back from seeing it (and boy is it a long movie...)

So now y'all are going to have to suffer through my incredibly long, ranty, spoiler-filled review. Following which I shall, naturally, ask for your thoughts.

So. First things first, two amazing scenes were deleted. The entire "The Other Minister" sequence was deleted (sans bridge-breaking, which was the opening scene), as was the scene where Dumbledore shows up at Private Drive, terrorizes the Dursleys some, and then leaves with Harry. Naturally this was a big disappointment.

Next up, my favourite scene in the whole book (me? Obsessed? No, not at all); Narcissa (Helen McCroy, an odd choice IMHO), tailed by an angry Bellatrix (who was perfectly casted), visits Snape (again, excellently casted) to beg him to help her son, Draco, accomplish "the task". Snape, as you know, takes the unbreakable. Cons of the scene; Bellatrix got, like, two lines. Exceeding the vow lines, of course. There was no question-answer session between her and Snape. I was very sad, since that was after all Bellatrix's only appearance in book six. Also, WHY DID NARCISSA HAVE BLACK HAIR?! Would it *really* have been that hard to make HM wear a wig? Also also, Helen McCroy looked *older* than HBC, who was supposed to be her older sister. Sigh.

Weasley Wizard Wheezes went alright, some minor adjustments to the "let's follow Draco!" scene; mainly, Draco didn't ditch his dear old mum, and there were more Death Eaters (including Fenrir Greyback and (I think) Bellatrix's huge!hair).

Train ride was alright, too, except Luna found Harry, not Tonks, and a mysteriously de-aged Flitwick greeted them, not Snape. And I know Flitwick has been mysteriously de-aged since movie 3, but I didn't figure it out until this movie when they actually said his name.

Pleasantly, the Hogwarts students decided to wear their robes again. They didn't in the third movie, drat them.

Slughorn... I didn't picture him so very whimsical. More corpulent and stuffy, to be honest. Though, the actor (whose name escapes me) did a fantastic job.

Quidditch tryouts were AWESOME. Cormac was exactly the way I imagined him, slimy and overbearing. We also suddenly meet Lavender, who both looks and acts the part of the ditz. Hermione instantly becomes preferable. Ron, for some reason, decides it's a good idea to bounce a large, leather ball off of his head. Numerous times.

Anyway. We see Harry win the lucky potion, much to poor Draco's dismay (god, I feel so *sorry* for Draco watching this. He's got these pathetic montages at intervals trying to fix the Vanishing cabinet, and first he puts an apple through, it comes back with a chunk missing, then later he puts a bird through, it comes back dead, and you hear him sobbing off screen. Brilliant (gorgeous) actor). Harry crushes on Ginny.

Harry gives Ron placebo lucky potion. Ron wins game. Ron snogs Lavender. Hermione sobs onto Harry's shoulder, is interrupted by Ron and "Lav-Lav", and attacks Ron with magical canaries that explode on impact.

More random stuff happens. Harry & Co. sans Hermione head to Burrow for Christmas. Harry voices suspicions about Draco. Arthur Weasley exposits handily about Vanishing Cabinets.

Oh, look! An interesting scene in which Bellatrix (accompanied by a half-bare-chested Fenrir Greyback) lights a Ring of FIRE around the Burrow. She taunts Harry with her little "I killed Sirius Bla-ack" routine and he runs after her. Ginny runs after him.

Bellatrix and Fenrir attack Harry and Ginny. Harry and Ginny are joined by Arthur, Lupin, Tonks, and I think one other person. We see a close up of Bellatrix pouting, then she flies into the air and blows up the Burrow. No one is hurt, oddly enough.

Later on, at Hogwarts, Harry walks in on Ron, who has just eaten Romilda Vane's love potion. Hilarity ensues until Ron is poisoned, saved, and is unconscious in the hospital wing. "Lav-Lav" bursts in, riding high on teenage hormones ("There's only one thing more potent than my Black magic! The power of TRUE LOVE! ...Teenage hormones!"). Ron starts mumbling Hermione's name. Tears! Smug smirk on Hermione's part!

Ron wakes up and remembers nothing. Oh, yeah, Katie comes back from St. Mungo's. Harry sees Draco run off, and follows him. He finds Draco sobbing in a bathroom and shouts at him because Harry is a heartless Gary Stu. Draco immediately retaliates by cursing him, thus removing him from woobie status until Harry uses a spell that practically cuts Draco in half. Draco becomes a woobie once more. Snape saves his life, though. Harry and Ginny hide The Book. Ginny kisses Harry and it's never mentioned again. BLAM? I think so.

Moving on. Harry steals Slughorn's memory, Horcrux scene happens, blah blah blah blah... Harry and Dumbledore travel to God-Forsaken Rock in the Middle of Nowhere and Dumbledore drinks a nasty potion, following which Harry is attacked by Dead People. Lots and Lots of Dead People. Dumbledore saves Harry with massive pyrotechnics. They return to the castle with the fake!Horcrux.

Draco corners Dumbledore and begins to cry. Bellatrix and some other Death Eaters show up. Bellatrix crows that Draco has done well and kisses... either his shoulder or his ear, I'm not entirely sure. Draco, however, is beginning to lower his wand. Snape shows up, kills Dumbledore, Death Eaters run away.

Bellatrix jumps up on one of the tables in the great hall, kicks all the cups to bits, then turns around and blows up all the windows, laughing hysterically all the while. Glass flies everywhere and she laughs psychotically. She kind of dances (no, seriously, dances) ahead of her fellows, shrieking with glee, and sets Hagrid's hut on fire. And then she does some strange, tribal looking dance in front of the flames (do you understand why I love HBC, now? Do you? She is amazing.)

Harry runs up, incensed. Bella starts to attack him, but Snape stops her saying that "he's the Dark Lord's!" Bellatrix, I kid you not, pouts at him like a little kid, as if to say "sure, ruin my fun" and stomps off.

Snape reveals that he is the Half-Blood Prince. He does not, however, deliver that wonderful line, "DON'T. CALL. ME. COWARD!" line. It would have been all the more dramatic because Alan Rickman is not a screamer. Nor is Snape. Still, it was cool. Harry got thrown backwards about 20 feet twice, first by Bellatrix then by Snape.

The rest of the movie consisted of blue-eyed, long-necked Daniel Radcliffe wangsting and announcing that he's not going to Hogwarts next year. Sadly, the Dark Lord does not suddenly appear and put him out of his misery. In fact, the Dark Lord is completely absent from the movie, even though the screenwriters had no qualms about adding Bellatrix scenes (perhaps as an apology for underusing her character so terribly in OotP...?).

So. What did everyone else think?

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(July 15, 2009 - 10:55 pm)

I think you will find there are many Harry Potter lovers on here, KittyKat! I have only recently become one. :D

submitted by Brynne, age 14, Flying away on
(July 22, 2009 - 1:36 pm)

That's fine, KittyKat! You're welcome on any

thread! Welcome to Chatterbox, by the way. XD

submitted by Megan M., age 13, Ohio
(July 22, 2009 - 2:34 pm)

WOOO! I saw it 5 minutes ago and thought it was really good! However...WEREN'T RON AND HERMIONE SUPPOSED TO BECOME PREFECTS? AND WHAT HAPPENED WITH THE BEGINNING? THE LONDON BRIDGE JUST COLLAPSING OUT OF NOWHERE, NO BACKGROUND, NO APPARENT REASON?!! WHY NOT SHOW THE SCENE WHERE DUMBLEDORE COMES TO #4, PRIVET DRIVE, INSTEAD??? HELLO!

Ahem. Sorry about that. I just wanted to complain. It's fun! But truth be tolde, I really enjoyed it. I'd reccomend it! It was much better than I thought it would be (reading everyone's comments).

submitted by Ima
(July 25, 2009 - 2:46 pm)

Yes, I know. I thought they were supposed to become prefects in the fifth one, actually. I still haven't seen the sixth one. I want to, though. But I'm enjoying hearing (typing?) people talk about it!

submitted by Brynne, age 14, Flying away on
(July 25, 2009 - 7:35 pm)

Yeah. And the Inferi were more Zombi-ish that Inferi-ish. They didn't even have Rons olw, Pigwidgeon (did i spell that right?). They didn't have Fleur and her *annoying* accent. They didn't have Bill. Why was The Burrow burnt? i have a feeling that they aren't going to have the wedding in the seventh movie. Why did they have to cut my most favoritest (hehe; favoritest) part out of the movie? Dumbledores funeral. WHY!!!??!?!?? They didn't show how Bellatrix didn't trust Snape. And they didn't even say who gave Katie the necklace. And i am going to stop now.

submitted by Meadow, age 11, IL
(July 28, 2009 - 9:59 am)

Ok I didn't read any of this thread because I haven't seen the movie yet, and I just started reading the books, and don't want to know the details...

But TNÖ, have you heard of Harvey Putter and the Ridiculous Premise?? Looney Lunkhead, or whatever her name is, is my cousin!!!!!!!! You can look up the add on youtube, it's a really weird movie, and really stupid looking, but I thought it sounded like something you would be interested in, I mean, it's a spoof on Harry Potter, anyone would be interested in that!!! :)

 

submitted by Laura
(July 28, 2009 - 1:17 pm)

i absolutely LOVED the movie, Bellatrix kinda scares me, but she is a great actress. i was very upset with how Fleur and Bill weren't in the movie AT ALL. and how could they not show the funeral? and have you seen the actors without makeup? honestly, there all like, in their thirties! (okay, exageration.)

but anyway, a good movie. ***** five stars!

submitted by Katie, age 11, Missouri
(July 29, 2009 - 10:35 am)

Bellatrix is SUPPOSED to scare you. I mean, after all... "You need to really want to cause pain. To enjoy it." :) But she is awesome nonetheless.

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(July 29, 2009 - 2:37 pm)

I'll have to look it up when I'm ungrounded from the computer and get my laptop back. The name itself interests me greatly. "Ridiculous Premise".

Speaking of HP spoofs, have you seen A Very Potter Musical? It's to die for (but a bit... crass... at times). Especially Voldy and Draco Malfoy.

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(July 29, 2009 - 10:50 am)

:) :) :) :)

No, I haven't, but it sounds familiar...

submitted by Laura
(July 29, 2009 - 2:28 pm)

10 Random yet awesome thoughts about the movie:

1. BellaTrix with her 80's hair was great, but Voldy should have come in to scare people to death, or just kill them.

2. "Lav Lav" was great. I loved the seen were she drew a heart on the door of the Hogwarts express.

3. The Death eaters made me dizzy when they were blowing up Muggle bridges.

4. Slughorn was great, but not really how I thought he would be.

5. Think about the difference of Riddle/Voldy when he was asking Slughorn about horcruxes, and when he was in COS. How old was he then, 5???

6. I love Alan Rickman as Snape! He is perfect.

7. Did the Death Eaters blow up the Dursleys and the Muggle Prime Minister, too?

8. Ginny does not help Harry get rid of The Half-Blood Prince's potions book, and their kiss was not hidden in the room of requirement!

9. If the 5th Harry Potter book does not come to me when I say Accio! I am demanding a refund.

10. Umm... that's all.

 

submitted by Mathilda B., Greensburg, PA
(July 31, 2009 - 6:39 pm)

1. Helena Bonham Carter is always awesome, especially in the roll of evil people (e.g., Mrs. Lovett, Morgan Le Faye, Bellatrix...). And yes, I was very sad that Voldy didn't make an appearance.

2. It's just a pity she wasn't introduced earlier in the series, seeing as how she's been around since book 1.

3. Meh. The movie needed more explosions. More! MOAR!

4. Yeah, I didn't imagine him so petulant. And with a mustache. He was brilliant, though.

5. I miss the CoS guy. He was perfect. The new guy just didn't have that cold-blooded murderer/charismatic leader air. He just sounded whiney.

6. Ironic, given Alan Rickman's about twice as old as Snape is supposed to be. Still, a rather excellent casting choice.

7. Nah. Alan Rickman just switched to Judge Turpin mode and sent them to Austrailia for fifteen miserable years. They'll come back and turn into deranged serial killers, you mark my words.

8. Movie!Ginny was super annoying. At least in the books she had the Rule of Cool to fall back on.

9. It won't come to you. I'm holding it prisoner. MWAH HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA! AH HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA! AH AH AH HA HA! *choke* *wheeze* *snirk* *snicker*

10. Tuesday is UFO day. 

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(August 1, 2009 - 12:57 am)

*Thumps TNO on the back to stop her from choking and wheezing*

submitted by Brynne, age 14, Flying away on
(August 1, 2009 - 1:57 pm)

I thought it was really good except for the ending.

submitted by Coco , age !!, Tel Aviv
(August 8, 2009 - 4:01 pm)

There's no way to make the ending cheery, if that's what you mean. It was meant to be... mildly depressing.

submitted by Mary W., age 11.63, NJ
(August 9, 2009 - 10:59 am)