Harry Potter and

Chatterbox: Pudding's Place

Harry Potter and

Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince came out today. I've just got back from seeing it (and boy is it a long movie...)

So now y'all are going to have to suffer through my incredibly long, ranty, spoiler-filled review. Following which I shall, naturally, ask for your thoughts.

So. First things first, two amazing scenes were deleted. The entire "The Other Minister" sequence was deleted (sans bridge-breaking, which was the opening scene), as was the scene where Dumbledore shows up at Private Drive, terrorizes the Dursleys some, and then leaves with Harry. Naturally this was a big disappointment.

Next up, my favourite scene in the whole book (me? Obsessed? No, not at all); Narcissa (Helen McCroy, an odd choice IMHO), tailed by an angry Bellatrix (who was perfectly casted), visits Snape (again, excellently casted) to beg him to help her son, Draco, accomplish "the task". Snape, as you know, takes the unbreakable. Cons of the scene; Bellatrix got, like, two lines. Exceeding the vow lines, of course. There was no question-answer session between her and Snape. I was very sad, since that was after all Bellatrix's only appearance in book six. Also, WHY DID NARCISSA HAVE BLACK HAIR?! Would it *really* have been that hard to make HM wear a wig? Also also, Helen McCroy looked *older* than HBC, who was supposed to be her older sister. Sigh.

Weasley Wizard Wheezes went alright, some minor adjustments to the "let's follow Draco!" scene; mainly, Draco didn't ditch his dear old mum, and there were more Death Eaters (including Fenrir Greyback and (I think) Bellatrix's huge!hair).

Train ride was alright, too, except Luna found Harry, not Tonks, and a mysteriously de-aged Flitwick greeted them, not Snape. And I know Flitwick has been mysteriously de-aged since movie 3, but I didn't figure it out until this movie when they actually said his name.

Pleasantly, the Hogwarts students decided to wear their robes again. They didn't in the third movie, drat them.

Slughorn... I didn't picture him so very whimsical. More corpulent and stuffy, to be honest. Though, the actor (whose name escapes me) did a fantastic job.

Quidditch tryouts were AWESOME. Cormac was exactly the way I imagined him, slimy and overbearing. We also suddenly meet Lavender, who both looks and acts the part of the ditz. Hermione instantly becomes preferable. Ron, for some reason, decides it's a good idea to bounce a large, leather ball off of his head. Numerous times.

Anyway. We see Harry win the lucky potion, much to poor Draco's dismay (god, I feel so *sorry* for Draco watching this. He's got these pathetic montages at intervals trying to fix the Vanishing cabinet, and first he puts an apple through, it comes back with a chunk missing, then later he puts a bird through, it comes back dead, and you hear him sobbing off screen. Brilliant (gorgeous) actor). Harry crushes on Ginny.

Harry gives Ron placebo lucky potion. Ron wins game. Ron snogs Lavender. Hermione sobs onto Harry's shoulder, is interrupted by Ron and "Lav-Lav", and attacks Ron with magical canaries that explode on impact.

More random stuff happens. Harry & Co. sans Hermione head to Burrow for Christmas. Harry voices suspicions about Draco. Arthur Weasley exposits handily about Vanishing Cabinets.

Oh, look! An interesting scene in which Bellatrix (accompanied by a half-bare-chested Fenrir Greyback) lights a Ring of FIRE around the Burrow. She taunts Harry with her little "I killed Sirius Bla-ack" routine and he runs after her. Ginny runs after him.

Bellatrix and Fenrir attack Harry and Ginny. Harry and Ginny are joined by Arthur, Lupin, Tonks, and I think one other person. We see a close up of Bellatrix pouting, then she flies into the air and blows up the Burrow. No one is hurt, oddly enough.

Later on, at Hogwarts, Harry walks in on Ron, who has just eaten Romilda Vane's love potion. Hilarity ensues until Ron is poisoned, saved, and is unconscious in the hospital wing. "Lav-Lav" bursts in, riding high on teenage hormones ("There's only one thing more potent than my Black magic! The power of TRUE LOVE! ...Teenage hormones!"). Ron starts mumbling Hermione's name. Tears! Smug smirk on Hermione's part!

Ron wakes up and remembers nothing. Oh, yeah, Katie comes back from St. Mungo's. Harry sees Draco run off, and follows him. He finds Draco sobbing in a bathroom and shouts at him because Harry is a heartless Gary Stu. Draco immediately retaliates by cursing him, thus removing him from woobie status until Harry uses a spell that practically cuts Draco in half. Draco becomes a woobie once more. Snape saves his life, though. Harry and Ginny hide The Book. Ginny kisses Harry and it's never mentioned again. BLAM? I think so.

Moving on. Harry steals Slughorn's memory, Horcrux scene happens, blah blah blah blah... Harry and Dumbledore travel to God-Forsaken Rock in the Middle of Nowhere and Dumbledore drinks a nasty potion, following which Harry is attacked by Dead People. Lots and Lots of Dead People. Dumbledore saves Harry with massive pyrotechnics. They return to the castle with the fake!Horcrux.

Draco corners Dumbledore and begins to cry. Bellatrix and some other Death Eaters show up. Bellatrix crows that Draco has done well and kisses... either his shoulder or his ear, I'm not entirely sure. Draco, however, is beginning to lower his wand. Snape shows up, kills Dumbledore, Death Eaters run away.

Bellatrix jumps up on one of the tables in the great hall, kicks all the cups to bits, then turns around and blows up all the windows, laughing hysterically all the while. Glass flies everywhere and she laughs psychotically. She kind of dances (no, seriously, dances) ahead of her fellows, shrieking with glee, and sets Hagrid's hut on fire. And then she does some strange, tribal looking dance in front of the flames (do you understand why I love HBC, now? Do you? She is amazing.)

Harry runs up, incensed. Bella starts to attack him, but Snape stops her saying that "he's the Dark Lord's!" Bellatrix, I kid you not, pouts at him like a little kid, as if to say "sure, ruin my fun" and stomps off.

Snape reveals that he is the Half-Blood Prince. He does not, however, deliver that wonderful line, "DON'T. CALL. ME. COWARD!" line. It would have been all the more dramatic because Alan Rickman is not a screamer. Nor is Snape. Still, it was cool. Harry got thrown backwards about 20 feet twice, first by Bellatrix then by Snape.

The rest of the movie consisted of blue-eyed, long-necked Daniel Radcliffe wangsting and announcing that he's not going to Hogwarts next year. Sadly, the Dark Lord does not suddenly appear and put him out of his misery. In fact, the Dark Lord is completely absent from the movie, even though the screenwriters had no qualms about adding Bellatrix scenes (perhaps as an apology for underusing her character so terribly in OotP...?).

So. What did everyone else think?

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(July 15, 2009 - 10:55 pm)

And Narcissa also had black hair instead of blonde. Grr.

Yes, I'd forgotten about the Felix scene. That was so funny;

Slughorn: [stage-whispering] /Harry!/

Harry: [also stage-whispering] /Sir!/

Brilliant.

As to the Pensieve discontinuity, I blame the fact that they keep getting different directors. Although Mr. Yates is doing DH as well, so they'll probably finish strong. 

 

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(July 18, 2009 - 4:55 pm)

Haha! XD That scene was hilarious.

submitted by Megan M., age 13, Ohio
(July 19, 2009 - 11:37 am)

Just saw the movie with my dad and little sister. My thoughts?

1. TOM FELTON WAS AWESOME. Awesome! He was like, the best part of the movie. And the best actor, as well (though they were almost all quite good). On the way back home, I was raving about how great he was... and I was ignored. :( But yes, he was fantastic. And *extremely* good-looking. Of course, HP then had to barge in while he was crying in the bathroom... sheesh. Annoying! And the vanishing cabinet thing... poor Draco. :( He was fabulous. *raves*

2. Yes, TNO (umlaut). I now understand your obsession with HBC. She was the second-best in the movie, Tom Felton being the first. I cracked up when she war-danced in front of the burning hut... my dad and sister didn't, though. And when she danced on the table and blew up the windows... yes, that was quite funny as well.  Excellent actress, and she portrayed Bellatrix perfectly.

3. Complaint: They utterly butchered Tom Riddle's character. He did indeed look like a little boy. I mean, he was only supposed to be a bit younger than me, but that actor must have been about eight. Or younger. Why? And would it have been so horrible to get the CoS guy for at least the Slughorn memory scene? I was quite disappointed about that.

4. Re: Harry's eyes. Yes. How hard would it have been to get the guy contacts? I mean, his eyes are really quite handsome blue eyes, as someone else said. But green contacts... they have no trouble blowing up bridges and windows and houses, how hard would it have been to get the lead actor a pair of contacts? Really...

5. How was Narcissa dark-haired? She may not have been terribly good-looking, but she was most definitely blond.

6. The kissing between Harry and Ginny. Could they have overdone that ridiculous RoR scene any more? I mean... it just got annoying, how predictable and corny that entire relationship was.

7. *fumes* They cut out the other minister scene AND the Durseley scene. What was with that restaurant and that bizarrely skinny waitress who Harry was obsessing over? Although I dread to think what Petunia and Vernon would've looked like, their last appearance they looked absolutely hideous...

8. The Inferi scene. Excellent. I mean, I basically had a conniption fit with the whole arm-out-of-the-lake thing, but nonetheless very well done. Of course, Maggie covered her eyes the whole time... Though they cut Dumbledore rantings about "don't kill them... my fault..." etc., regarding his family... but still, great scene.

9. "Lav-Lav" was an excellent actress as well, and quite comical, as was Rupert.

Overall, probably the best HP movie so far, definitely the funniest. Tom Felton was the *best* part, HBC was hilarious, and all the other cast members, despite not being as good, were also excellently cast. The special effects, though they were definitely showing off (@ Lena), were nevertheless really terrific. I enjoyed it very much.

submitted by Mary W., age 11.54, NJ
(July 18, 2009 - 5:24 pm)

First off; YES. Tom Felton was AMAZING. Personally I thought HBC was the best actor, but he's definitely second. *Maybe* third, after Alan Rickman (who is much better looking as Snape then Judge Turpin, I might add), even though AR didn't have much screen time. TF is very good at crying and still being gorgeous, I might add. And he's much better looking than DR with his *huge* neck. And Draco was such a woobie in this one... *sniffles*

Indeed, I miss the CoS Tom Riddle. He was excellent, and gorgeous. He just had kind of that... evil-kid air. The new guy... didn't. And his nose was far to big. I mean the least they could've done is get someone who at least looked like the previous actor? And heck, RPattz is a 23-year-old playing a 17-year-old. Age is of no issue in movies. They could've gotten the original guy.

Helen McCrory had two streaks of blonde hair but the rest was black. Here, here's a picture (hope it works, it's very small):

 

See the black? On top? 

Certainly very far from the "drowning person", platinum blonde appearance of Narcissa Malfoy described in the books. And, as I said, she looked older than Bellatrix. Rather taller than I imagined her, too. Brilliant actor, though. Would've liked her as Andromeda, as I've mentioned. Although there would still be the she-looks-older-than-Bellatrix issue. (Not that it's her fault HBC looks about fifteen years younger than she really is...)

Oh, yes, I went to see it again today and (even though I knew it was coming) I jumped about a foot and- to my great embarrassment- shrieked like, well, like a little girl when the Inferi grabbed Harry's arm.

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(July 18, 2009 - 10:35 pm)

Okay, I will have to see it then.

submitted by Lena
(July 19, 2009 - 7:16 am)

I aggree with ALL you said Mary W., ALL the things.  Both the things about Tom Felton.  *blushes*

submitted by Meadow, age 11, IL
(July 19, 2009 - 9:10 am)

SPOILER-ISH!

I felt sorry for Draco too.  People who haven't read the books but only seen the movies will understand him more now!!!!!!!!  I would probably cry because the bird died, too, like Draco.  I jumped when the inferi grabbed Harry, but I didn't scream.  I knew it was going to come.  But still, I jumped.  We were in the second row and the heads seemed even more close up than in the other movies.  WAY close up.  WHY did they burn the burrow?  Where is the wedding going to be?     

submitted by Meadow, age 11, IL
(July 18, 2009 - 7:03 pm)

Draco wasnt crying because of the bird my older sister thought that too but he was crying becuse Voldy was going to kill him.I jumped too when the Inferi grabbed his arm too.I dont know why the burrow burned too but they said it was a key scene I think it was becuse it was showing how Tonks will risk her life for Lupin same with Ginny and Harry.Ginny is awsome.

submitted by Rachel P, age 11, GA
(August 10, 2009 - 11:32 am)

Exactly! They cut the ginormous battle and added the Burrow burning? I didn't see any point to it. Plus Bill, Charlie, and Fleur weren't in it at all. @ whomever said Narcissa was blond: they had the sides of her hair blond, but the top was black - ????

 

But I still thought is was good, I just like to complain sometimes about movies :). Especially HP ones. 

submitted by Allison P., age 12
(July 19, 2009 - 9:27 am)

I complain too. Like for The Golden Compass, Harry Potter, Inkheart... blah, blah, blah.

submitted by MeadowSage, age 11, IL
(July 19, 2009 - 12:34 pm)

I am going to see this in one hour exactly. Well, not exactly.

submitted by JFB, age 13, Here and There
(July 19, 2009 - 11:18 am)

I hope you like it!

submitted by Lena
(July 19, 2009 - 5:14 pm)

Wait! People, come back! I wasn't done hearing about it yet...

submitted by Brynne, age 14, Flying away on
(July 22, 2009 - 9:12 am)

hey well sorry 4 interupting sorry im new and im tryin to join a group ill leave if you want im just tryin to get a group ps the reason i came here is cause i love hp too!

submitted by KittyKat, age 11, Georgia
(July 22, 2009 - 9:49 am)

Welcome, KittyKat! You can definitely join. :)

submitted by Lena
(July 22, 2009 - 10:41 am)