Harry Potter and

Chatterbox: Pudding's Place

Harry Potter and

Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince came out today. I've just got back from seeing it (and boy is it a long movie...)

So now y'all are going to have to suffer through my incredibly long, ranty, spoiler-filled review. Following which I shall, naturally, ask for your thoughts.

So. First things first, two amazing scenes were deleted. The entire "The Other Minister" sequence was deleted (sans bridge-breaking, which was the opening scene), as was the scene where Dumbledore shows up at Private Drive, terrorizes the Dursleys some, and then leaves with Harry. Naturally this was a big disappointment.

Next up, my favourite scene in the whole book (me? Obsessed? No, not at all); Narcissa (Helen McCroy, an odd choice IMHO), tailed by an angry Bellatrix (who was perfectly casted), visits Snape (again, excellently casted) to beg him to help her son, Draco, accomplish "the task". Snape, as you know, takes the unbreakable. Cons of the scene; Bellatrix got, like, two lines. Exceeding the vow lines, of course. There was no question-answer session between her and Snape. I was very sad, since that was after all Bellatrix's only appearance in book six. Also, WHY DID NARCISSA HAVE BLACK HAIR?! Would it *really* have been that hard to make HM wear a wig? Also also, Helen McCroy looked *older* than HBC, who was supposed to be her older sister. Sigh.

Weasley Wizard Wheezes went alright, some minor adjustments to the "let's follow Draco!" scene; mainly, Draco didn't ditch his dear old mum, and there were more Death Eaters (including Fenrir Greyback and (I think) Bellatrix's huge!hair).

Train ride was alright, too, except Luna found Harry, not Tonks, and a mysteriously de-aged Flitwick greeted them, not Snape. And I know Flitwick has been mysteriously de-aged since movie 3, but I didn't figure it out until this movie when they actually said his name.

Pleasantly, the Hogwarts students decided to wear their robes again. They didn't in the third movie, drat them.

Slughorn... I didn't picture him so very whimsical. More corpulent and stuffy, to be honest. Though, the actor (whose name escapes me) did a fantastic job.

Quidditch tryouts were AWESOME. Cormac was exactly the way I imagined him, slimy and overbearing. We also suddenly meet Lavender, who both looks and acts the part of the ditz. Hermione instantly becomes preferable. Ron, for some reason, decides it's a good idea to bounce a large, leather ball off of his head. Numerous times.

Anyway. We see Harry win the lucky potion, much to poor Draco's dismay (god, I feel so *sorry* for Draco watching this. He's got these pathetic montages at intervals trying to fix the Vanishing cabinet, and first he puts an apple through, it comes back with a chunk missing, then later he puts a bird through, it comes back dead, and you hear him sobbing off screen. Brilliant (gorgeous) actor). Harry crushes on Ginny.

Harry gives Ron placebo lucky potion. Ron wins game. Ron snogs Lavender. Hermione sobs onto Harry's shoulder, is interrupted by Ron and "Lav-Lav", and attacks Ron with magical canaries that explode on impact.

More random stuff happens. Harry & Co. sans Hermione head to Burrow for Christmas. Harry voices suspicions about Draco. Arthur Weasley exposits handily about Vanishing Cabinets.

Oh, look! An interesting scene in which Bellatrix (accompanied by a half-bare-chested Fenrir Greyback) lights a Ring of FIRE around the Burrow. She taunts Harry with her little "I killed Sirius Bla-ack" routine and he runs after her. Ginny runs after him.

Bellatrix and Fenrir attack Harry and Ginny. Harry and Ginny are joined by Arthur, Lupin, Tonks, and I think one other person. We see a close up of Bellatrix pouting, then she flies into the air and blows up the Burrow. No one is hurt, oddly enough.

Later on, at Hogwarts, Harry walks in on Ron, who has just eaten Romilda Vane's love potion. Hilarity ensues until Ron is poisoned, saved, and is unconscious in the hospital wing. "Lav-Lav" bursts in, riding high on teenage hormones ("There's only one thing more potent than my Black magic! The power of TRUE LOVE! ...Teenage hormones!"). Ron starts mumbling Hermione's name. Tears! Smug smirk on Hermione's part!

Ron wakes up and remembers nothing. Oh, yeah, Katie comes back from St. Mungo's. Harry sees Draco run off, and follows him. He finds Draco sobbing in a bathroom and shouts at him because Harry is a heartless Gary Stu. Draco immediately retaliates by cursing him, thus removing him from woobie status until Harry uses a spell that practically cuts Draco in half. Draco becomes a woobie once more. Snape saves his life, though. Harry and Ginny hide The Book. Ginny kisses Harry and it's never mentioned again. BLAM? I think so.

Moving on. Harry steals Slughorn's memory, Horcrux scene happens, blah blah blah blah... Harry and Dumbledore travel to God-Forsaken Rock in the Middle of Nowhere and Dumbledore drinks a nasty potion, following which Harry is attacked by Dead People. Lots and Lots of Dead People. Dumbledore saves Harry with massive pyrotechnics. They return to the castle with the fake!Horcrux.

Draco corners Dumbledore and begins to cry. Bellatrix and some other Death Eaters show up. Bellatrix crows that Draco has done well and kisses... either his shoulder or his ear, I'm not entirely sure. Draco, however, is beginning to lower his wand. Snape shows up, kills Dumbledore, Death Eaters run away.

Bellatrix jumps up on one of the tables in the great hall, kicks all the cups to bits, then turns around and blows up all the windows, laughing hysterically all the while. Glass flies everywhere and she laughs psychotically. She kind of dances (no, seriously, dances) ahead of her fellows, shrieking with glee, and sets Hagrid's hut on fire. And then she does some strange, tribal looking dance in front of the flames (do you understand why I love HBC, now? Do you? She is amazing.)

Harry runs up, incensed. Bella starts to attack him, but Snape stops her saying that "he's the Dark Lord's!" Bellatrix, I kid you not, pouts at him like a little kid, as if to say "sure, ruin my fun" and stomps off.

Snape reveals that he is the Half-Blood Prince. He does not, however, deliver that wonderful line, "DON'T. CALL. ME. COWARD!" line. It would have been all the more dramatic because Alan Rickman is not a screamer. Nor is Snape. Still, it was cool. Harry got thrown backwards about 20 feet twice, first by Bellatrix then by Snape.

The rest of the movie consisted of blue-eyed, long-necked Daniel Radcliffe wangsting and announcing that he's not going to Hogwarts next year. Sadly, the Dark Lord does not suddenly appear and put him out of his misery. In fact, the Dark Lord is completely absent from the movie, even though the screenwriters had no qualms about adding Bellatrix scenes (perhaps as an apology for underusing her character so terribly in OotP...?).

So. What did everyone else think?

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(July 15, 2009 - 10:55 pm)

My mom is taking my little brother, his

friend, and me to see it today...o.O

submitted by Megan M., age 13, Ohio
(July 16, 2009 - 9:10 am)

It was better than I expected it to be, but your mileage may vary. It's greatest redeeming factor, for me, were all the added scenes with Bellatrix, who got sufficient screen time to make me forgive them for deviating from the books. Obsessed? Me? Not in the least, heh.

Also, Dumbledore still has those dratted jingle bells in his beard. And Narcissa wasn't platinum blonde like she was supposed to be. Why they couldn't just find a blonde actress instead of Helen McCroy (who, in case you don't know, was cast as Bellatrix but then she got pregnant so HBC got the role instead... rather happy about that, to be honest). I mean, they could have cast her as Andromeda, who is supposed to look like Bellatrix. I mean, she doesn't, not at all, but it would have been funny nonetheless...

Also also, I miss the Tom Riddle actor from CoS. The new one just didn't have the same... aura... about him. He looked and sounded like a little boy. Sigh.

Also also also, Daniel Radcliffe still has an abnormally gargantuan neck, and his eyes were still blue. Pretty eyes, yes, but *blue*. 

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(July 16, 2009 - 1:08 pm)

I saw it yesterday.  As a movie, OK.  As a movie based off a book, I have to read the book again.  I haven't read the Harry Potter series sence I was like, what?  Nine?  I don't really remember. 

I have NO idea if I like BellaTrix or not.  I know I like Snape.  Draco Malfoy, well, he seems more sensitive in that movie than all the others.  i like that.  I like Draco in that movie, in the others, not so much.  After I finish reading all the twenty library books that we have I'm going to walk into my rooma and pull out the first Harry Potter book and burn my eyes out with it.  

submitted by Meadow, age 11, IL
(July 16, 2009 - 6:10 pm)

I just got home from seeing it about an

hour ago. It was good, LOL. :) The only

problem is that the boys (as in my brother

and his annoying friend XD ) will NOT stop

talking about it now, and when my brother

gets into something *sighs* he REALLY

gets into it. Anyway, the movie was cool.

I'll stop my blabbering now. *lowers voice

to a whisper and leans next to TNO* Don't

worry. My little brother is just as obsessive

as you are... o.O

submitted by Megan M., age 13, Ohio
(July 16, 2009 - 5:38 pm)

My little sister, Luna (real name), who's four watched the movie last night.  Right now she's playing with Miles, who's two.  They're pointing pencils at each other and yelling "Avra cadavra!" in their little-kid accent.

submitted by Meadow, age 11, IL
(July 16, 2009 - 7:50 pm)

(this is in response to a Rachel who posted on the Marauder's Era HPRP)

1. You do not call Voldy moldy. EVOR. *glare* *hugs Voldy* *runs away very fast before Voldy can retaliate* hem.

2. Well, sure, Bella's a complete nut. Never said she wasn't, not even on the Next-Gen HPRP in which I write her. Just because a character's completely wacko doesn't mean they can't be awesome... Take, for example, Sweeney Todd, Mrs. Lovett, Bellatrix Lestrange, Ursula, Erik/The Phantom, Azkadellia (though wholly justified in her madness, hah...), River (the only one on this list who is *not* a villain), Angelus, Spike, ZIM (well, he's a protagonist villain...)... characters are from Sweeney Todd, Sweeney Todd, HP, Broadway version of The Little Mermaid, Phantom of the Opera, Tin Man, Firefly, BtVS, BtVS, and Invader ZIM, respectively, in case you're wondering.

3. Gah, yes, Inferi arm lunging suddenly out of the water nearly gave me a heart attack even though I knew it was coming. Loved that scene. Lots and lots of Dead People + Insane Pyrotechnics = awesome in my book.

4. Small, purple balls of fluff with huge eyes are ALWAYS cute, dumpling.

5. "Oh but I do, dumpling! We're so very alike, you and I! Girls with ambition!" /obsession

6. Me? Crazy? *twitch* Whatever gave you that idea?

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(July 16, 2009 - 11:14 pm)

I can't wait to see it. I think I am probably obsessed (Yeah, definitely obsessed) with all the Harry Potter movies and even more with the books. My brother (21) LOVES HBC. And her crazy hair and creepy cackle.

submitted by JFB, age 13, Here and There
(July 17, 2009 - 9:14 am)

Hannah and her fellow classmates walked into their common room, babbling about this and that.Hannah caught some fragments of their conversations, some thing about their dad finding a rare plant called duskwort. And how boobertoober pus could cure some skin ailments. Hannah stored as much useful information she could hear, in her head, in case it would come up in a test. Hannah ran up to her common room to see that all her things had been placed neatly beside her bed, on cabinets, hanging on hooks. None of this surprised Hannah in the slightest, for after coming to Hogwarts for two years, she had learned the house elves took all their luggage up to the dormatories, and made sure everything was ready for the students. Hannah touched her bed covers,and sure enough, her covers were warm. She pulled the covers back. But there were no heating pans in sight. They must have heated it by magic! She said to herself. She reached for a little metal case with bars on the front, on her cabinet. she looked inside, there sat her pygmy puff, purple and fluffy, and the cutest little eyes you could ever come across. Hannah poked her fingure in through the bars, intending to pet it, but instead the little puff ball nibbled her finger. "Ouch!" said Hannah in surprise, as she quickly pulled her hand back. "I bet you're hungry, aren't you?" she said adressing her pet. But of course, the pygmy puff, being a pygmy puff, didn't say anything. "Here you are!" said Hannah reaching into her pocket groping for some food she had snuck away from the feast and wrapped in a napkin. She undid the little knot in the fabric and pushed some of the food in through the bars; a carrot, pea, and bread. "there"she said. "How are you feeling now, Juniper?" Juniper goobled up all the food, but still looked quite sad. "Hmmm" said Hannah thinking. "Aha!" she said dipping her clean finger into the water jug beside her bed. she opened a little slot on the top of the case and let drip from her finger some droplets of water. Juniper waddled over to it and darnk thankfully. Hannah smiled at it.She slid the grate shut, slipped into her pajamas, and being so tired from the fetivities of the evening, went straight to bed.

To be continued.

By Hannah P.

Some characters, objects, and ideas,based on the works of J.K.Rowling.

 

 

submitted by Hannah P., age 13, GA
(July 17, 2009 - 12:19 pm)

Wrong thread, dearie. This ain't the roleplay, this is the Half-blood Prince Movie thread.

submitted by Emily
(July 17, 2009 - 12:38 pm)

SPOILERS

I'm considering whether or not to go. I prefer movies with actual plots than 'oh yeah, look what we can do with special effects!' stuff. Would you say there was actually a plot? And in general, would you recommend it?

Some people on the MuseBlog were asking, though - they need the Burrow for the seventh movie! They can't cut out the wedding! Do you think they'll just rebuild it by magic?

submitted by Lena
(July 17, 2009 - 11:21 am)

You should go. Some of the things are like "cmon! they didn't need that!" But some scenes were very good, and they used many sentences from the books. When people see a movie they like to criticise the things they didn't like but that doesn't mean the whole thing is bad. Who is your favorite character?

submitted by Hannah P., age 13, GA
(July 17, 2009 - 12:22 pm)

Agreed. I was pleasantly surprised (but then I had very low expectations...) with how the movie turned out. As I said, they deviated a bit but the overall plot was the same (and we saw more of Bellatrix...).

As for my favourite character? Bellatrix. But you knew that. XD Snape didn't have a big enough part to warrant a reprise as "best character in the movie", sadly.

submitted by TNÖ, age 16, Deep Space
(July 17, 2009 - 1:33 pm)

I like Sirius, Lupin, Luna, Lily, and Snape sometimes. And thanks for the review! :)

submitted by Lena
(July 17, 2009 - 5:20 pm)

I saw it yesterday! Random thoughts (with lots of spoilers, by the way):

- Everybody in the theater either screamed or jumped when the first Inferi arm came out of the water (I did both). But the Inferi looked more like cursed mummies than corpses...

- I agree, Narcissa wasn't anything like I picture her. She was barely weepy at all, and she did look older than Bellatrix.

- I felt so sorry for Draco during this movie. I also think Tom Felton did a great job portraying Draco's anxiety and pressure and worry and stuff.

- They totally cut the battle scene! And the funeral! Urgh! But I did love the part where everyone raises their lighted wands, I started crying (for the second time). For the record, I am a softie when it comes to movies and books.

- (Harry) "And the pincers." *weird clicky motions and noises until Hagrid looks at him funny* *Allison cracks up laughing* Geez, I loved that part. Harry was so funny when he took Felix Felicis.

- Okay, I totally didn't get this. At the very end of the sixth book is when Harry breaks up with Ginny, but in the movie, that's when Ron finally says okay. How are they going to work that out?

- I loved the actress they chose for Lavender, plus I think they did a great job with Lavender's character. The hospital wing scene? Perfect.

- Did anyone notice how they had contradiction with the Pensieve? In the fourth movie, where Harry goes into a memory, it's perfectly clear, and Harry is in the memory - in other words, just like the book. But in this movie, the memories are all foggy and dark, and Harry isn't shown in the memory at all.

 

That's all I have time for at the moment. But overall, I though they did okay with the movie.

submitted by Allison P., age 12
(July 18, 2009 - 8:11 am)

I saw it on Thursday night. Really good!! 

I totally agree with you Allison! For one:

Luckily I went with my dad but was sitting alone. When Dumbledore died, I was just sobbing, tears were literally streaming down my cheeks! *grabs kleenex*. So yeah....*sob*.

Second, Harry was so hilarious in the Felix scene! It was so awesomely funny. I loved the lily-petal fish scene. Though not in the book, it was a nice touch.

Third of all: HOSPITAL WING SCENE! I was nearly crying I was laughing so hard. (Again, good I was sitting alone!) It was HILARIOUS!!

At first, I thought "Lavender" was "Romilda Vane", because she strangely isn't in any of the other movies....hmm...Wink She was GOOD, though.

And the Burrow Christmas scene....WHAT??!!!!?? I did not get that AT. ALL. How're they supposed to film the seventh movie, huh?

SEVENTH.... MOVIE.....HURRY.....UP...ALREADY...

See y'all! Love ya!

submitted by Julia , age 13???, Another Realm
(July 18, 2009 - 3:55 pm)