I have a

Chatterbox: Blab About Books

Dislike of popular books thread!
I have a...

I have a couple of friends who agree with me on this, so I don't feel as weird saying this as I would otherwise: I really don't like Harry Potter. I'm sorry, all you Harry Potter lovers (Potterheads?), but this has to be said: honestly, the books are 2 dimensional. They basically have the same plot, that's basically "Oh my god, Voldemort's alive again and gonna kill us all! Oh, wait, he won't, because Harry will save us!" Seven times. Seven times. The first few times it was ok, but then it just got super repetitive.

and  I also don't like Divergent. I mean, the plot and world building is great, but I don't really like Veronica Roth's writing that much.

so what about you guys? Any popular books that you don't like? Or will you please explain to me why everyone likes these books so much? 

submitted by the doctor, age 14, the tardis
(November 27, 2013 - 10:17 am)

I'm just going to ignore everyone's rude remarks about Harry Potter, because otherwise this post would take a very long time, no one would read it because it was so long, and I don't want to argue.

Twilight: I know I don't really have the right to tear this apart since I haven't actually read it, but it is sitting next to my bed waiting to be read just so I can form my own opinion. I will share what I think about it once I've read it.

To reply to other's dislikes:

Divergent: I didn't think it was so bad. It just wasn't really my taste. I'm not a big fan of overly violent novels. And also, *Spoiler alert* I've heard about the series incredibly depressing ending. *Spoiler ends*

The Hunger Games: I was very hesitant going into these books, but I was somewhat surprised. The first book is not NEARLY as violent I thought it would be. Once again, not really my style, but I did like it. The second book was a little bit more violent the first, but still good. Now, I can't really say that I liked Mockingjay. It was so depressing. A lot of people you care about die and Katniss spends about half the book sitting in the hospital addicted to morphling. But overall, I liked the books, much more that I thought I would before I read them. I know that everyone had their opinions, and I have been somewhat hasty to judge books before I read them too, but I'm starting to try and read something before I badmouth it (Twilight), or don't bad mouth it at all. Who knows, maybe it's different than you thought it would be and you end up liking it.

The Heroes of Olympus: I definitely get where some of you guys are coming from. I still like the books and intend to finish reading them, but they don't hold a candle to the Percy Jackson books. I feel like they are being pumped out too quickly, without much thought. Reading the PJ series felt like magic, I could re-read any of those books multiple times. It was so much more engaging to read them through Percy's eyes, hearing his thoughts. There are way too many narrators of HoO. When I'm reading it, I don't get the feeling of savoring every word, dying to know what happens next. Also, some of the characters in HoO are soooo one dimensional. *Hint, hint* Miss boring Piper, and Mr Perfect Jason.

Like I said earlier, everyone deserves their own opinions, but these are mine.

 

 

 

submitted by Ivy
(November 29, 2013 - 4:35 pm)

I feel the same way about the Percy Jackson books. I want more and more.Smile I am glad you are going to finish them. What book are you on?

submitted by Coco, age 12, Kansas City
(January 4, 2014 - 1:06 pm)

I'm done with The House of Hades. What book are you on?

submitted by Ivy
(January 4, 2014 - 5:14 pm)

I get where you are coming from with Harry Potter. I only read the first three, but they all just didn't have enough adventure and action in them for me. Hardly any violence and hardly any battles, just not my cup a tea. But I did like them! Just not the best. . . . 

Now with HoO, I don't get it at all. I actually liked them a little better then PJ. I loved the different view points and that they are a lot moe intense then PJ. PJ annoyed me at times, because RR had to hold back because it was for younger readers, but in HoO it is for older reader, so he didn't have to hold back. He let it all out and I just LOVED it! It actually reminded me a little of my own writing, so that mad me happy.

I haven't really read many other 'popular' books. But really, I like every single book I read. There hasn't been a single I can remember that I hated. Each book has a something in it I absolutly LOVE!!!  

submitted by Corina
(November 29, 2013 - 6:07 pm)

I liked PJO and HoO and I still don't have HoH :O I liked how the POV was omniscient (look it up peeps I learned it in English) in HoO. And PJO I loved too! The Kane Chronicles was good too, in my opinion, because I love Egyptian mythology. 

...But at least I'm reading The Girl Who Circumnavigated Fairyland in a Ship of Her Own Making. Books besides the popular series are getting really underrated! 

I thought Divergent was good. I didn't really like the sequel because Tris and Four were all romancy and I am a no no for romance. I'm reading Allegiant and I don't know what to think of it yet.

Twilight: UGH. I'm not going to read it.

And I loved Harry Potter so I'm just going to ignore the other comments.

As for the Hunger Games, I get where people say it's bad. I mean, I'm in the middle with it. I read the series, but I don't remember much. I want to see the new movie, but I also want to see The Desolation of Smaug soon!!

 

submitted by Moss, age 13
(December 1, 2013 - 9:00 am)

I haven't read The Hunger Games or Harry Potter yet, but I've read The Kane Chronicles, Percy Jackson and the Olympians, and The Heroes of Olympus.  I really liked them, however I think there are a lot of narrators in HoO  and it was kind of weird SPOILER with the whole Nico liking Percy thing.

What do you think?  

submitted by Makayla, age 11, NC
(December 31, 2013 - 10:13 pm)

That was super creepy. RR got way too.... weird. My school took the book out of circulation because of that.

submitted by Coco, age 12, Kansas City
(January 4, 2014 - 1:24 pm)

Honestly, I thought Nico was sooooo cool until then. :/ Oh well.

submitted by Coral~, age 13
(January 9, 2014 - 9:35 pm)

Regarding Harry Potter, I actually liked it quite a bit, more for the wry British humor and interesting characters than for the actual killing Voldemort plot. Because you always knew Harry was going to win, so thinking about that too much seemed silly. What I liked least about it, though, was how Rowling, for all her entertaining writing, had to include a Deus ex Machina in order to tie up the story. I wish the Peverels had been introduced earlier, so the Wand and Stone didn't seem so inserted for Harry's use. I also hated how Sirius, Lupin and Tonks had to be killed.

I don't really read "popular books," but that said, I don't because nothing sounds interesting. Twilight sounds too romance-y, Hunger Games waaaay too violent, and Divergent too much of a knock-off. Heroes of Olympus could be better. The characters' "voices" sound too similar; only Percy and Annabeth seem most authentic, and that's because I loved them so much in the first series. 

submitted by Everinne, age 14, Old Fashioned
(November 29, 2013 - 11:41 pm)

I agree! Harry Potter= ):

submitted by s.E, age 11, MA
(December 2, 2013 - 7:39 pm)

I have a strange distast for Harry Potter for a reason unknown to me. I used to love it.... but then I didn't. So there you go.

Popular books. I guess that's another reason the October 8th thing frustrated me. I feel like at this point Rick Riodian just needs to stop writing. I know what it's like to get attached to a character, but he needs to calm down. Heros of Olympus is just because he can't give up on writing his characters, I guess. Or something like that. I sort of feel like he could write something horrible and the whole world would read it, while (going back to Oct. 8th) Matthew Cody could write something wonderful and only a few people would read it.

That's not true, but it's kind of how I feel about the Hero's of Olympus.

The missing serise. Margret Peterson Haddix. Read her book TURNABOUT or THE SHADOW CHILDREN serise and you will understand why I can't stand it. SHE CAN DO BETTER!  

And Ender's Shadow. I don't like Ender's Shadow. Bean is an unpleasent, introverted loner. I dislike him. He was better in Ender's Game.  

submitted by Theo W., Dark, dreary places
(December 3, 2013 - 9:28 pm)

So, I guess the popular book that I really can't stand is Twilight (and the following three books) but I doubt I need to get into that. Also the teenage, clichéed love books that are oh-so-popular. Cannot. Stand. Reading about girls who are depressed because some guy (who probably is Captain of some sports team) does not love her because she isn't a cheerleader (most likely, she's nerdy or geeky or whatever else you find in these books - just as long as she is not popular-  and has been blinded by love because sporty guys are the cutest *sarcasm*).  

I just remembered a popular book! It's called Skinny and I always see it in magazines. I'm sorry but, after reading the summary, all I have to say is that this book is not sending the right message to teenage girls.

And Lauren Conrad. I know she's an author but I do not know the name of her books so I can't name one but she writes about beauty and confidence or something. I read an interview with her once and she said something like: I had a big advantage growing up because I was blonde and tanned well. That got me bad because this makes lots of girls think they have to dye their hair blonde and burn themselves in the sun to be pretty.

I personally liked The Hunger Games (except the last one) and Divergent (although the second one just wasn't as good) and I love Harry Potter but that is just me.

I started and failed to read The Red Pyramid. I think that The Kane Chronicles really just cannot hold a candle to PJO.

@Theo W.- Is Ender's Game worth reading?  

submitted by Elizabeth, age 14, Germany
(December 5, 2013 - 12:41 pm)

@ Elizabeth: Oh my gosh, I feel the same way about teen romance type books. It's entirely pointless! I'm really, what would anyone get out of those books? They've got no value at all. And they just drive me insane because while so many girls claim they wouldn't be that shallow, they act just like that! They become entirely hooked on these books, and slowly start to act like the characters though they don't realize it.

I just read the summary of Skinny, and I have to agree.

I COMPLETELY AGREE! It makes me sick when girls feel they have to be tan and dye their hair. That's part of the reason I call myself Blonde Heroines Rule. The story goes deeper than just hair color. It's supposed to stand for "it doesn't matter your hair color, weight, or whatever, all girls can rock." But then they see others trying to tan (it's like a death warrent for skin cancer), and they go and just destroy themselves! It's sad.

And I didn't like The Kane Chronicles either! They're no where near as good as PJO. To me, it's sort of like Rick took everything that wouldn't have worked in PJO, and decided to put it into another book.

submitted by Blonde Heroines Rule
(December 7, 2013 - 10:32 pm)

@BHR- Exactly! Tanning is bad for you! Sadly, a lot of girls my age have not gotten that. I have really pale skin but I'd rather have that than burning my skin to a crisp in the sun. Also, I wish that books these days were more inspiring for girls or sending better messages than "If you change yourself, people will like you". That's just wrong and it leads to girls wearing TONS of make-up on their face. It IS sad and sometimes I wish I could tell people that they're pretty without all the concealer and eyeliner that they wear everyday. 

submitted by Elizabeth, age 14, Germany
(December 13, 2013 - 12:47 am)

I wouldnt say that tanning itself is bad for you--tannning booth style tanning is, and getting sunburned is, but ive lived in India since i was 5 months old, and I have a crazy tan just from being outside. 

That was probably a bit disconnected from what Elizabeth and BHR are saying, so I dont really know if my post made any sense.

submitted by the doctor, age 14, the tardis
(December 13, 2013 - 11:35 am)