This is somewhat
Chatterbox: Inkwell
This is somewhat
This is somewhat weird, but I thought I would post it anyway. I know it doesn't make sense and is not very good.
Alone with my mind
sitting down in a room
thoughts slice through
darkness
where is the light
why is no one here
no one to comfort
to help me through
streaming tears
tasting like salt
bitter and sweet
as they run down and fall
down, down
I pick up a pen
turn on a small light
and write
on a crumpled paper
I write my tears away
and write out my thoughts
thinking only of the letters
they comfort me
the words streak across the page
filling my mind with those words
this is what I do;
my passion,
my life,
I write.
Comment if you want!
submitted by ***Hannah, age 14, An old musty bo
(May 12, 2010 - 9:18 pm)
(May 12, 2010 - 9:18 pm)
It's a great poem! Really! And it does make sense, mainly. There are a few things that were a bit hard-to-follow but they're all minor details, really.
There was no punctuation, for 1 thing. That's perfectly fine, for a poem. Many lack it. But then, at the end, you included a semicolon, a period, & 2 commas. It was a bit odd to see punctuation suddenly spring up like that. This is just my opinion, but I think it would be better if you either took it away or added it to the rest of the poem. I think I'd prefer the latter. It seems more like the kind of poem that should be punctuated.
And there was one part that was a bit confusing.
streaming tears
tasting like salt
bitter and sweet
Good, but it sounds almost as if you're comparing the tastes of your tears & salt in that both were bitter & sweet. I doubt that's the case. Maybe you could try rewording it?
streaming tears
bitter and sweet
tasting like salt
perhaps, or
streaming tears
bitter salty
and sweet
or something like that. I prefer the former.
(May 13, 2010 - 5:20 pm)
Very nice, Hannah. I really like the message of this poem because I can totally relate. I'm going to add on to what Ima posted, so sorry if I'm sorta repeating what she said. I'll start with a bit of a punctuation thing. The lines: "where is the light/why is no one here" are a little choppy. You could insert a question mark: "where is the light?/why is no one here?" to make that better, but I would suggest reconsidering those lines as well. The "where is the light" line is very good, and gets my mind going, wondering what's going on. Then "why is no one here" strikes me as a bit off the rhythm and not totally going with the previous line. I like that fact that you have two questions in a row - the flow of that is nice - but I think you could even do something like: "where is the light/where are the people?" Or something way better than that. But if you get my drift... you could make it even more uniform here.
Another critiquing idea, before I go all out on praise. I would consider revising are the lines "the words streak across the page/filling my mind with those words." I notice that "words" is used in those two lines in the same way. You might want to cut out the second "words," possibly replacing them with another word. All depends on where you want to go with those lines. Here's an example: "the words streak across the page/filling my mind/this is what I do;/my passion, my life, I write." Personally, I think that flows best, though it's all up to you. You're the poet!
This is the paragraph that you definitely deserve to read after such a great poem. I do like the lines: "as they run down and fall/down, down." It's nice imagery and makes me feel the tears streaming down my cheeks. The beginning: "Alone with my mind/sitting down in a room/thoughts slice through/darkness" sets the mood very well and makes me feel alone and separated from the world. The thoughts slicing through the darkness shows me (see, not tells me) how this room and situation is really dark and depressing, though you are able to conquer this sadness in the end by writing.
Overall great poem, and I certainly hope you don't mind my critique (which you can ignore if you want). I also want to take this opportunity to tell the thread to go to the top, since it's doing no good here at the bottom!
~Leaf
(May 17, 2010 - 11:20 pm)