Hey everyone! I'm

Chatterbox: Inkwell

Hey everyone! I'm

Hey everyone! I'm kinda new at this but I thought it would be cool to have a story/poetry thread where we could post stuff we're working on, and get feedback and suggestions. you can post the part of the story or poem that you want help/suggestions with and others can coment. I'll start. this is a poem i'm working on, but am having trouble finding a good rhyme that makes sense for the last line of the 3rd stanza. (I only posted the 2 and 3 stanza's here)

Normal
0

Did
you ever hear a cricket's lullaby,

And
wondered where he learned the words?

Have
you ever found a worm in the earth,

And
questioned who told him where to hide from the birds?

 

Who
has watched a spider weave his web,

And
not thought of who showed him how it is done?

Or
who has felt magic in a firefly's dance,

And
not asked why he needs to know only one?

 

If anyone has any helpful  comments/sugestions or ideas, please let me know! (I hope it doesn't mess up my format...)

Normal
0

submitted by Gwynnia, age 15, Traveling with
(October 5, 2009 - 12:53 pm)

Eh. Vision is the most workable rhyme I can come up with, but its accentuation isn't quite right. Look for online rhyming dictionaries - there are a lot of words that rhyme with done, but if you're willing to dig through them, you should find something better. Pretty nice poem, though, however you rhyme it.

 

-EH

submitted by Emily H. :), age 14, Sparks, NV
(October 5, 2009 - 7:34 pm)

Thanks Emily, I'll keep working on it Laughing

submitted by Gwynnia, age 15, Traveling with
(October 6, 2009 - 9:22 am)

Hi there, Gwynnia! (Is that your real name, or just a pseudnym?)  I realy liked reading your poem, but I do have some constructive critizism for you.  If you feel that I am communicating this the wrong way or disagree with me, feel free to argue.

I felt that the beat was off throughout the poem.  This is solved easily.  All you have to do is maybe clap the poem out or say it out loud to get the feel of the rhythm.  (Do you play an instrument or sing, or maybe even compose music?  It's the same basic principle.)  The last line of the first stanza, And questioned who told him where to hide from the birds?, is too long.  My suggestion would be to find a shorter synonym for questioned

You don't have to rhyme your poem unless you want to, so don't worry about that.  Many of the best works of poetry do not rhyme.

I am not sure how much of this stems from the awkward rhythm, but the poem, dispite its beautiful ideas, is choppy and awkward.  Maybe you could expand the vocabulary a little to make it flow more.  Find synonyms for words, see what works for you.

Overall, I thought that it was a great start; it just needs a little nudge in the right direction.

I myself have a problem with the story that I am writing.  The story is based on Greek mythology, about a young girl who died and has gone to the Underworld.  She needs to cross the River Styx, but as she drowned,no one knows where her body is and they canot place a golden drachma in her mouth for her to pay Charon, the boatman, for passage.  The part where she gets free passage is awkward, and I don't know how to make it work.  Maybe a fresh set of eyes (aka you) will help.

 

I don’t know how long I was in there, but it couldn’t have been long.  The only clear memory I have is of when I escaped.  I was sitting next to an old man with a scraggly beard.  I was about to count the spirits in the room again (at my last count, there were 258) when he spoke up. 
“You are not like the others,” he commented.  “I cannot explain it, but you are special.  Tell me, who were your parents?”
I felt that there was no harm in telling him, so I replied, “My father was Pyrrhus xxxx, my mother Helena xxxx.”
“Strange.  Ordinary humans, yet your flame is so strong…  It blinds me.  She must be someone special; no ordinary human has such a bright aura.  I wonder…” he trailed off, muttering to himself in an undertone.  So I was startled when he suddenly proclaimed, “Yes.  You must be someone important, child.  You have urgent business in the Underworld.  Therefore, you are special enough to be given this.”  He handed me a golden drachma.  I looked at him in awe.  No one, absolutely no one, gave away their ticket across the river.  Who would willingly submit themselves to this for eternity?  I looked at the coin in his ethereal palm, torn.  I would give anything to be rid of this, this, nothingness, the waiting.  Anything, I realized, except this.
“No.” I said quietly.  The old man looked startled.  “You are very kind, but I could not cross, knowing that you would never follow, knowing that I was responsible.  You have a great heart, and I hope that you enjoy life in the Elysian Fields.”
I did not realize that Charon was watching until he spoke.  “In all of my millennia ferrying you spirits across that accursed river, I have never seen someone so selfless as you.  I only wish…” he trailed off, apparently torn.
“It’s alright.” I told him, mainly to reassure him.  “I don’t mind.”
“Well, I do.” Charon said, apparently having made up his mind.  “To Tartarus with the consequences.”
“But he’ll destroy you,” I said, distraught.  “I can’t have that on my conscience.  I couldn’t bear for anything to happen to you because of me.”
“That is why you will have no choice in the matter.  One way or another, you are going over that river, if only because you re too selfless for your- or anyone else’s- good.”

submitted by Megan, age 14, Alagaesia
(October 6, 2009 - 3:28 pm)

Wow! I love this story! You sound just like me. My best suggestion for the story ( even if you didn't ask for my help, sorry if im being pushy) is to have Charon not be listening but feel her aura too, because him being so nice is a little strange. Other than that, I absolutely love it! You should try to get something published!

submitted by Anne U, age 11, Chicago, IL
(October 6, 2009 - 7:12 pm)

*dies from astonishment and joy*

*finds self in the Realm of Hades*

*bribes Charon and sets off to find main character*

You really mean that?  You love it?  You think that I should be published?  Wow, that's absolutly amazing!  My family loves my writing, but, well, they're my family.  They're supposed to love my writing.  If you want to read more, I started a post on Chatterbox a long time ago to share my story and get constructive critisism; the link is below. (http://www.cricketmagkids.com/chatterbox/inkwell/node/6029).  

I always welcome critique!  I like the idea of him feeling her aura, but I kind of wanted to have some old guy ranting about her destiny and stuff.  Maybe I can put that in while she's waiting in line for Judgement.  About your comment that Charon seems too nice, that's actually the point.  All of the myths talk about the Underworld as a dark and dismal place; not exactly where you want to spend the rest of enternity.  Everyone is supposed to be cruel and heartless.  In my novel, Corinna discovers that the myths have it all wrong, that most of those in the Underworld, including Charon, are actually quite nice.  This is an integral part of the story; I can't change that, as it would change the entire novel.  (Unless of course you meant his willingness to be destroyed in order to ferry Corinna across the river...)

I'm probably going to change a lot in this section of my story; as I look at it I see multiple errors.  That is alright though, because this is just the rough copy that I typed up and didn't even proofread afterwards.  So I will take your suggestions to heart and welcome others as well.  Thank you for your glowing complimants and helpful critiques.

Whoops, I have to go.  I'm about to recieve my Judgement!

(Just an afterthought: What do you mean, I sound just like you?)

submitted by Megan, age 14, The Realm of Ha
(October 7, 2009 - 3:43 pm)

Wow Gwynnia, this is just..this is just magical! Seriously, I love it! It's sounds like a poem and a dance and a song mixed in one.

submitted by GloWorm, age 12, USA
(October 7, 2009 - 2:56 pm)

And I also disagree, the beat is right on. You can't say it fast and work through it, I find it slow likes a summers daydream.

submitted by GloWorm, age 12, USA
(October 7, 2009 - 2:58 pm)

My suggestion for the last stanza, is to say something with the sun. E.G 'Like a whispering sun' or 'taking place for the sun' or such. :)

submitted by GloWorm, age 12, USA
(October 7, 2009 - 3:01 pm)

Thanks eveyone :) My mom actually had the suggestion of Begun, which I really liked.

submitted by Gwynnia, age 16
(March 2, 2011 - 1:22 pm)