Lately I've been
Chatterbox: Down to Earth
Lately I've been
Lately I've been wondering what makes a person right, particularly when it comes to religion. Just so you know, my parents are Christians, I'm a Christian, all my family members are Christians. Coming from a Christian's point of view, what makes us right about other religions? Don't Muslims and Mormons and Hinduists believe just as strongly in their religion as I do in my God? If they do, then what makes me think that God is the TRUE way other people think that their way is the TRUE way? I know that we have the Bible to prove that God exists and sacrificed himself for all of us, but still...
This has been on my mind a lot this week. I'd love to hear what you guys think.
submitted by Livv S., age 12, Lancaster, PA
(May 2, 2014 - 8:25 pm)
(May 2, 2014 - 8:25 pm)
I think that no religion is evil and that the whole Crusade thing of trying to convert the "pagan" to Christianity is kind of narrow minded. Christ never said to go out and convert people, He said to love your neighbor and your God. Basically, you don't have to get involved with "fixing" other people.
I think that all religions are "true" and that if their principles are followed, everyone will find their "heaven." I don't think there is any "wrong" religion; the Muslim extremists just simply distort the true purpose of what their religion dictates so that they can vent their own personal anger.
If you really get down to the bare bones of religion, you find that they are all really similar in a lot of ways.
I remember a book called One God: The Ways We Worship Him
Admin
(May 3, 2014 - 7:06 pm)
Yeah, I think so too. The basic thing is to believe that God died for us, and to love each other. It's actually simple when you break it down.
(May 8, 2014 - 7:24 am)
Well, what I have to say about religion, no religion is better than the other. Mormons aren't better than Jews, and Muslims aren't better than Hindus. It just doesn't work like that. (I respect people's beliefs about their religion though.) I don't necessarily have a religion, but I do believe in God and other aspects of other religions like Hinduism. Bit of a rant sorry...
(May 7, 2014 - 6:41 pm)
Admin: Gollum, you made an interesting point, but I tend to agree it's not 100% CB appropriate.
(May 8, 2014 - 8:31 am)
I think everyone's truth is true for themselves. You believe in God, so God exists for you. Some people don't believe in Him, and He doesn't exist for them. I think it's okay for people to have different beliefs. It makes life interesting. If you want to believe that your way is the true way, then it is true for you. We can't monitor other's beliefs.
(May 8, 2014 - 9:40 am)
Some people think that what you believe is how the world is. I am a Baptist Christian, and I don't believe that other religions are wrong, exactly. I just think of it as a different perspective. I've also wondered that because my friend is Hindu, and I was talking to her at recess about religion. Her father is athiest, and her mother is Hindu. She told me she felt forced to believe her mother's beliefs, and didn't quite agree with them herself. But, she said she didn't really believe anyhing and felt empty. So that led me to wondering. If I had grown up in a household with different religious beliefs, would I feel the same about my beliefs? I decided that my calling to God felt too strong, and that I would always feel that way, no matter what.
(May 9, 2014 - 9:11 pm)
As other people have said, I don't believe that one religion is the one true religion. Morality and correctness depend less on what you worship and more on how you worship it. There are militant atheists and radical Christians. I have atheist role models and Christian role models and Muslim role models and agnostic role models and all sorts of other religions. And honestly I think that people shouldn't involve themselves in the beliefs of others. Maybe one belief system is true, but there is no implication of what belief system is, so there's no point in trying to prove it. Maybe everyone has their own separate truth, or maybe all religions are versions of the truth, with one overreaching concept similar to what Everrine and Livv mentioned earlier. (And yeah, there's some interesting resources on that. My religion teacher keeps on talking about How Do You Spell God, for instance, though I haven't read it myself.)
(May 9, 2014 - 10:34 pm)
So, going off topic here, We are allowed to talk about Muslim, Buddist, Hindu, and other gods, but it is banned to talk about my God. Does that sound fair to you?
(May 10, 2014 - 6:31 am)
There is no "my God is better". Buddha isn't better than God, God isn't better than Buddha. It's not like that. I don't think there is one necessarily "right" religion. Believe what you believe.
(May 10, 2014 - 1:20 pm)
I don't think my family has a religion.
My parents never talked about God or Jesus all that much, so I never did either. One day my dad told me about how Christmas started, and he talked a little bit about the birth of baby Jesus, but he didn't go into much detail.
I find it hard to believe that some all-powerful, external being created us all...
But I guess if that didn't happen, it leaves us with no explanation for the Big Bang. So I dunno. I'm kinda leaning towards "we came from monkeys" but maybe it was God.
Who knows?
(May 10, 2014 - 6:40 am)
About that whole evolution topic... To me, saying that we evolved from monkeys seems even more impossible than saying that something greater did. It's like justifying that if you a handfull of scrabble pieces onto a tabletop over and over again, you would eventually come up with a line of Shakespeare. Not even going into the fact that you'd have to make the scrabble letters and whatnot. To me it just seems so random that it wouldn't work. Wouldn't it just be easier to believe that someone greater had a plan and purpose in making us? To me it is.
Not saying you have to agree with me, or anything.... This is just what I think.
(May 10, 2014 - 4:41 pm)
@ S.E.
I think the idea that we aren't allowed to talk about the Christian god is a bit of an exaggeration. We're talking about him (Him?) right now, aren't we?
@SomeonePlusFour
Evolution is rather more complicated than 'we came from monkeys' (specifically, we share a long-extinct common ancestor with certain types of apes) but so far it's the most scientifically sound theory (and I use theory in a vernacular sense here - in a scientific sense, 'theory of evolution' means that it's fully accepted by scientists just like, say, the theory of gravity) that we have. It doesn't, contrary to popular belief, exactly contradict the Bible - it does, of course, if you take every part of the Bible literally, but there is no need to do that. If God is a thing that exists, God may well have set evolution into motion, and created the Earth in what six days was to him (Him?), but what's six days to God as opposed to six days to us? Wouldn't it be different? Especially considering that a day as in '24 hours' is measured by the rotation of the Earth, which, if God was creating it at the moment, wouldn't exist? So a day would have been in God's measure, and we don't know what that is.
TL;DR: there's no need to let taking the Bible literally get in the way of scientific fact, because the two are not mutually exclusive.
(May 10, 2014 - 10:19 am)
Whether or not a person believes in God seems to be a matter of how their brain is set up. I'm pretty sure most scientists say that there's a gene that seems to indicate whether or not a person will be capable of believing in a higher power. So, if a person has that gene, then how they choose to worship that higher power is entirely up to them. So according to that, no religion is "correct."
(May 10, 2014 - 5:19 pm)