I know that

Chatterbox: Blab About Books

Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows
I know that...

I know that there are quite a few threads devoted to Harry Potter already, but this one is specifically for the last one! (not that we have to stay on topic.) What did everybuggy think? I thought it was pretty good except that the wandering around with the tent was pretty boring and felt like JKR was grasping for something to fill the pages. I LOVED Snape's story, though. :( And in a weird way I liked how JKR took away everything cliché about Dumbledore and made him more human. What about the rest of you?

P.S. This is my Blab about Books challenge. Three more to go!

submitted by Lena G, age 11
(February 26, 2009 - 12:13 pm)

I'm currently in the middle of rereading it for the second time (it's my 3rd time reading it total, and certainly not anywhere near my last). #7 is my personal favorite out of the whole series. It's also the one that made me cry the most :).

WARNING: those who haven't read it and don't want it spoiled, stop reading this comment and quickly move on to something else. :)

I don't think JKR could have done the last battle any better. That's my favorite part - from the time Harry returns from King's Cross Station with Dumbledore to the end. I could barely stop crying throughout that scene - the happy parts and the sad parts. At the part where Dobby died, I had to put the book down for a good five minutes because I couldn't see the words through my tears. And the happy and sad tears just flowed at the part where Kreacher leads the house elves out of the kitchen and says "Fight! Fight! Fight for my Master, defender of house-elves! Fight the Dark Lord, in the name of brave Regulus! Fight!" Occasionally, I'll just pull the book off my shelve, turn to the end, and just read that scene without reading any other. JKR had so many loose ends to tie up, and she managed to tie them them all up and do it in a masterful way.

#7 also holds fond memories for me: it was the first (and last) time my mom allowed me to go to one of those midnight publishing parties at a bookstore. My at-the-time best friend, a fellow H.P. fanatic, and I dressed up as Luna Lovegood and Professor Trelawney (I was Trelawney) and ran around the bookstore for several hours with other friends we met there, talking, eating up cafe food, playing games, and having a blast. After that, due to my friend's very tolerant mom (who held our place in line for those hours we were jumping all over the place), my friend, her mom, her brother, and I were about the fifth in the store to get our books. We were having a sleepover that night, but her mom wouldn't let us open the books until we got in the house. We went straight to her bed (which we'd beforehand set up with cushy reading pillows) and opened it immediatly. We always made sure to stay within the same two pages of each other, so we could momentarily exclaim, talk, laugh, or cry about the same thing, before delving back into the story. Then her H.P. reading mom (acting as only a parent can *sigh*) made us go to bed at only 2:00 am; and then her mom stayed up all night reading! Humph. We read through breakfast, but when my dad came to pick me up from her house, he was shocked about how little sleep we'd had and took away my book until I'd taken a nap. Parents. I still managed to finish it late that day, luckily. :)

Wow.....that's a lot of writing. You don't have to read it all, I apologize for my ranting.

 

But I love Deathly Hallows!

submitted by Allison P., age 12
(February 27, 2009 - 3:33 pm)

That's okay! I love it too.

submitted by Lena G, age 11
(March 1, 2009 - 9:01 am)

The order in which I liked the harry potter books (from favorite to least so), is 3rd, 1st, 2nd, 7th, 4th, 6th, 5th. They were good. Funny that nobody read the new JKR book... whats its name?

submitted by Willa
(March 1, 2009 - 11:24 pm)

You mean Tales of Beedle the Bard? It was really good!

But not as good as 7... best book I have ever read! Oh, I LOVED the epiologue... and the final battle... and everything... I did think it was a pity that Neville didn't get to finish Bellatrix off, but Mrs. Weasley did a fine job! And Snape's tale... so sad... and that talk with Dumbledore in King's Cross... I love it how JKR managed to, as per every book, put in that talk with Dumbledore, even when he's dead! I mean, how much better does it get?!

7 brings back fond memories for me as well, Allison P. My family was on vacation, and my dad always read the books to us. I'm the eldest, and the other kids hadn't read any yet (well, one sister was up to three, but not seven, duh). But 7 had just come out, and my father and I wanted to read it so badly that we started it while on vacation. We were in a hotel, though, and the other four kids and my mom were in the hotel room sleeping or whatever, so we couldn't read in there. We were forced to go out into the hallway and sit against the wall reading quietly so as not to disturb other guests. Every now and then a maid would walk by with her cleaning trolley, and I don't think we looked like the perfect picture of sanity, if you know what I mean...

submitted by Mary W., age 11, Bordentown, NJ
(March 2, 2009 - 11:46 am)

The Tales of Beedle the Bard. Personally, I didn't really like it. It just semed like a lot of fluff.

submitted by Lena G, age 11
(March 2, 2009 - 12:26 pm)

*gasp!* You like the 5th book least??!!!!!!! That one is tied with #7 for my favorite!!!!!!! Wow, Allison, you really typed A LOT!!!!!:):):):)

submitted by Bekah P., age 12, in TWO, North Dakota
(March 3, 2009 - 4:34 pm)

Me too. But hey, we're all entitled to our own opinions!

submitted by Lena G, age 11
(March 3, 2009 - 6:16 pm)

Actually DH was my least favorite of the series, maybe because all of my favorite characters died and Harry failed to stay dead. I found the epilogue unrealistic and rather too rosy-cheeked for my liking.

I'll admit Snape's memories were perfect, if predictable, and made me cry for a good ten minutes. On the other hand, the Dumbledore-Has-A-Past thing was too sudden and out of the blue, although not entirely unexpected.

She didn't kill half the people I though she was going to; I was sure that either Ron or Hermione would get the chop.

Of course I was very pleased that she didn't kill Draco, as he was up in my top ten list...

However she killed Snape, killed Bellatrix, killed Voldy, killed Fred...

Harry's coming back made absolutely no sense at all. I was not happy.

And there were hundreds of pages of aimless wandering that, while vital to the plot, were achingly boring to read.

Though... I did immensely enjoy the scenes involving Bellatrix. :) 

submitted by TNÖ, age 15, Deep Space
(March 3, 2009 - 8:37 pm)

Yeah, she's so evil she's funny...

submitted by Lena G, age 11
(March 4, 2009 - 8:51 am)

I thought she was a very well-thought out character. She's ridiculously twisted, as you said, and fanatically loyal to Voldy. She's very skilled and very fast. And... in a weird sort of way I sort of admire her (though at the same time pity her) for determinedly loving someone who would never, could never love her back in any way. 

Though I do feel sorry for Rodolphus having to live with her. She must have driven him nuts.

submitted by TNÖ, age 15, Deep Space
(March 5, 2009 - 1:29 am)

Or maybe Rodolphus was the same way.

submitted by Lena G, age 11
(March 5, 2009 - 6:10 pm)

I meant, she must have driven him crazy because she was always fawning over the Dark Lord.

submitted by TNÖ, age 15, Deep Space
(March 6, 2009 - 9:35 am)

I think all Voldemort's supporters were always fawning over him.

submitted by Lena G, age 11
(March 18, 2009 - 8:07 am)

Nah, most of them were dead terrified of him. Lucius Malfoy, for example.

submitted by TNÖ, age 15, Deep Space
(March 23, 2009 - 1:08 am)

Can you explain more about why you weren't happy with Harry coming back, TNO? Just curious.

submitted by Allison
(March 5, 2009 - 3:59 pm)